| News | Contents | Wayne Medicine 1999 | Next Article | Previous Article |
Cellular Cross-Talk
By Jeanne Fitzgerald
Research paves the way for new
multiple sclerosis therapies
![]() |
Dr. Dore-Duffy is one of the only PhDs in the country who is involved in administering a multiple sclerosis clinic. |
| "Basically science is a lot of common sense and imagination. As scientists, we often use jargon that sounds so lofty and sets us apart from others. Science really is a lot like cooking, using the right ingredients, going step by step, and serendipitous timing. I tell my students, If you use your head, you won't make mistakes." |
This is how one eminent Wayne State faculty member describes the recipe for success that has resulted in her worldwide recognition in the field of neuroimmunology. The scientist is Paula Dore-Duffy, PhD, professor of neurology and immunology / microbiology, at the Wayne Sate University School of Medicine. Her research focuses on cellular aspects of multiple sclerosis (MS), one of humankind's most mysterious diseases.
Breakthroughs in science often result when there has been a fusion of cultures and disciplines. Dr. Dore-Duffy's unique career spans the clinical and basic research aspects of MS. She started her research career in viral immunology, moved to prostaglandins in autoimmune disease, and is now focused on neuroimmunology. One of the only PhDs in the country who is actually involved in administering an MS clinic (or any medical clinic for that matter), Dore-Duffy is also an internationally recognized basic scientist who specializes in the cellular and immunologic components of the blood brain barrier that distinguish the central nervous systems of MS sufferers.
| The blood-brain barrier is giving Dr. Dore-Duffy new insight into multiple sclerosis. | ![]() |
Dr. Dore-Duffy co-directs the Wayne State University Multiple Sclerosis Center along with Robert Lisak, MD, chairman of WSU's department of neurology and specialist-in-chief of neurology at The Detroit Medical Center. Dr. Dore-Duffy is also chief of the neuroimmunology division in the department of neurology. Well over 1000 patients are enrolled in Wayne State's MS program at the present time.
Multiple sclerosis has perplexed physicians and scientists since it was first described in 1835 in a 37-year-old woman by J. Cruveilhier, a French doctor working at the famous Hospital Pitie-Salpetriere in Paris, where the woman worked as a cook. He wrote with compassion of the progressive weakness and debilitation of the woman's limbs, speech, and vision - all in the face of unimpaired intelligence and comprehension - and her ultimate demise from an infectious lesion on the sacrum. Since then science has learned more about the disease and its epidemiologic pattern, but identification of the fundamental cause still eludes researchers and the suffering of individuals in the prime of life continues to plague their physicians.
| Physicians treating patients with MS often meet with frustration. Striking young (age 20-40), usually healthy people, with a 1:5/1 preponderance of women, it cycles unpredictably through remissions and exacerbations. |
Multiple sclerosis is a clinical diagnosis associated with demyelination of nerve sheaths in the central or peripheral nervous system appears. Presenting symptoms include paresis, paresthesias, visual impairment and incoordination. Mental, sexual, urinary and respiratory dysfunction may occur later in the disease. Physicians treating patients with MS often meet with frustration. Striking young (age 20-40), usually healthy people, with a 1:5/1 preponderance of women, it cycles unpredictably through remissions and exacerbations.
Scientists believe MS may be an auto-immune-like disease such as lupus and other clearly identifiable autoimmune disorders. Immune system irregularities, such as substantially increased amounts of immunoglobulins in the cerebrospinal fluid and activated T lymphocytes and enhanced B lymphocyte activity in the blood, are found in MS patients. But many theorize that MS may also have an infectious origin, since it is prevalent in certain parts of the world such as North American and Europe. MS is less common in hotter climates such as those countries near the equator.
There also appears to be a genetic component. People with a family history are 12 to 20 times more likely to get the disease. Although some therapies are known to be briefly palliative, nothing cures MS. Because there is no animal disease which spontaneously occurs that is comparable to human MS, it is difficult to study in a laboratory model, although experiments can induce lesion formation in animals that looks somewhat like multiple sclerosis. In animals it's called experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). Says Dr. Dore-Duffy, "If we test a drug in EAE, it does not mean it's going to definitively work in MS. The animal model may not be the human disease. The problem may be that when the physician diagnoses MS, the disease is in a chronic phase. We do not know what originally induced it."
Paula Dore-Duffy's research transitions of the last 20 years, both direct and indirect, have led to her current work in neurologic diseases, particularly where the immune response is thought to be involved. The area she is currently investigating is the role played by the blood-brain barrier in inflammatory diseases. The BBB, as its called, plays a huge role in MS and other neurologic diseases. The blood-brain barrier, that is, the microvasculature of the brain, is responsible for maintaining homeostasis and hemostasis. This barrier allows or disallows substances from the blood to gain access to the brain. It is very important because it affects how the brain regulates the whole body.
Dr. Dore-Duffy's blood brain barrier focus started with her participation on a multidisciplinary National Institutes of Health Study Section, that included investigators who worked on stroke and traumatic brain injury, as well as MS. For several meetings in a row she sat next to a colleague, a basic-science oriented clinician who maintained that "you immunologists", i.e. Dore-Duffy, did not study the blood-brain barrier adequately. After a couple of years of conversation, this eminent colleague convinced her of the importance of the brain's microvasculature and taught her how to isolate microvessels from the brain.
Dr. Dore-Duffy is interested in the way the cells of the blood-brain barrier talk to each other. Comprising the microvasculature are endothelial cells, which line the vascular tube; pericytes that sit next to endothelial cells, a protein matrix, also called the basal lamina, that encases everything. On the tissue of the basal lamina sit the astrocytes, multifunctional cells, which form connections with the basal lamina. Together they form the multicellular regulatory organ called the blood-brain barrier.
![]() |
This brain cell, as seen under an electron microscope, illustrates the entire blood-brain barier. |
All of these cells "talk" to one another constantly and this is how they maintain normal function, says Dore-Duffy. "For instance, let's say you're climbing a mountain and your body is getting less oxygen in the blood. These are the cells that will pick up that low oxygen signal. They're like a sensor. Like an early warning system. One thing these cells will do in response to hypoxia is to form more vessels, so there is more surface area, through which you can absorb more oxygen. The cell regulatory mechanisms are thought to be a key to unlocking some of the doors to multiple sclerosis." Hypoxia, says Dore-Duffy, is a good example of cellular adaptation to injury. The cells talk to one another and try to restore normal function. There are many common elements cellular responses in inflammation, stroke and traumatic brain injury.
For example in stroke, plugs form or stenosis or platelet aggregation develop, all of which occur on the luminal surface of the blood-brain barrier. In stroke and trauma, damage and cell death take place when blood flow stops. Compensatory mechanisms will then take place at the blood-brain barrier level through the interactions of barrier cells. In traumatic brain injury you have tearing of the blood-brain barrier, and shear stress, which is like a vibration. All of those cause changes in the cells and how they talk to one another.
Says Dr. Dore-Duffy, "What happens to us in response to all of these changes is determined in large part by what these cells do. Sometimes their compensatory mechanisms are good and sometimes bad." In all forms of blood-brain barrier insult - which includes not only stroke and head injury, but also MS - there is an element of excess leukocyte migration into the brain, which is usually deleterious. She explains, "Leukocytes are the white blood cells. Under normal conditions, a few white cells go into the brain to kind of check things out. Normally they just go in and then out. They are usually monocytes or other cells involved in innate immunity. They help in repair; they are the first line of defense called immune surveillance. They can be helpful, but they can become detrimental when they are activated in great numbers."
In the early 1990s, Dr. Dore-Duffy's work described how the leukocytes, particularly the monocytes, interact with the blood brain-barrier in excess. In MS, the leukocytes migrate into the central nervous system and chew up the myelin sheath, which insulates the nerves, just like rubber insulates electrical wires. These cells release cytokines and prostaglandins, which promote cell injury and, in part, cause the debilitating symptoms of MS.
To examine this phenomenon more deeply, Dr. Dore-Duffy set up cultures of the microvessels. One of her papers, "Endothelial Activation in MS" (published in Neurology in 1994), is still cited frequently. This finding was very important says Dore-Duffy because, "In order for leukocytes to migrate you need a permissive barrier. The barrier becomes permissive under conditions of activation because they express a number of cell surface molecules, which are called adhesion molecules. The leukocytes recognize these adhesion molecules, and they stop as they flow through the blood. If there are no adhesion molecules, then they continue on their way."
Dr. Dore-Duffy and her colleagues isolated the microvessels from autopsy tissue and stained them to identify adhesion molecules. She utilized a special type of microscope called a laser cytometer, which shoots a laser beam into the tissue with an antibody that has a fluorochrome (a fluorescent marker). In looking at the expression of one of the adhesion molecules on the endothelium called E-selectin, an endothelial cell activation marker, Dr. Dore-Duffy took an antibody directed against E-selectin conjugated with a fluorochrome marker - when the laser hits the fluorochrome, the computer senses the energy released from the fluorochrome and translates it to a specific color on a color scale. It prints a picture of the cell based on fluorescence intensity. Other previously used techniques, such as FACS analysis which also gives a semi-quantitative indication of antibody binding, simply wouldnt work with microvessels. They are much too large.
The laser cytometer has allowed scientists to see the actual cell activation and reception process. Dore-Duffy and colleagues discovered that microvessels from MS patients were activated with multiple adhesion molecules, both in areas where there were existing plaques and in areas which appeared to be putatively normal. What those results told them is that microvessels all over the white matter were primed or permissive for leukocyte. Says Dore-Duffy, "Basically we found what was responsible for the permissive barrier. How the barrier became activated was another question."
She then began to think about the differences between MS patients and patients with traumatic brain injury. Leukocyte influx occurred in both cases. Traumatic brain injury is characterized by leukocyte migration and demyelination, similar to what is seen in MS. The difference is, it stops, whereas in MS, demyelination is chronic, multifocal and it waxes and wanes. This may suggest to her an abnormality in a regulatory mechanism involved in acute inflammatory responses.
Her attention then turned to an intriguing little cell, which was part of the blood-brain barrier communication network, called the pericyte. In the scheme of the blood brain barrier cellular cooperative, the pericytes had been thought to play little or no role in blood-brain barrier permissivity. Through close examination of the cellular activity, Dr. Dore-Duffy noted that the pericytes were actually involved in important "communication" with the endothelial cells (the lining of the microvessels). Using the laser cytometer and other sophisticated equipment, she showed that white blood cells - leukocytes - actually cluster around the pericytes on their way through the blood brain barrier. This may be because pericytes secrete cytokines or regulatory proteins or have receptors that attract leukocytes.
What's more, the pericytes are able to activate T-cells. Dr. Dore-Duffy and her co-workers hypothesize that it is the pericyte that helps select T-cells to invade the brain and to inhibit migration when not needed. Exploring the pericyte regulatory mechanisms, that may explain neurologic damage both at onset of the disease and in perpetuation and relapse appears so promising, it has resulted in the awarding of a $380, 000 grant from the National Multiple Sclerosis Society. It may be possible to interrupt this cross-talk between pericytes and leukocytes and prevent their migration into the central nervous system.
Dore-Duffy credits the very supportive research environment at Wayne State and The Detroit Medical Center, which enabled her to establish this exciting new endeavor with its promise of help for patients with MS. "We have a strong neuroscience group at Wayne State and a large group of dedicated scientists who work on multiple sclerosis. A strong MS clinic also enables her to study human cells.
| Dr. Dore-Duffy is also a teacher and mentor. Here she is pictured with research assistant Thomas Beaumont and research associate Xuquian Wang in her lab. | ![]() |
Dr. Dore-Duffy was recruited to Michigan by Dr. Robert Lisak 10 years ago from a tenured position at the University of Connecticut where she was director of its MS program. She moved here with her husband and three young children. "Although I was quite happy in Connecticut, I came to Wayne State because of the MS program Dr. Lisak proposed to develop. Southeast Michigan has a variety of excellent clinical venues, which meant my husband was able to find a good position, as well." Dr. Dore-Duffy's husband, Michael Duffy, MD, a gastroenterologist, works at Beaumont Hospital as director of the gastrointestinal training program.
Dr. Dore-Duffy is very pleased with her new grant and research directions. Her only
complaint is that success and recognition have led to her appointment on the editorial
boards of five professional journals, a number of grant review panels, as well as election
to nine major professional societies. Certainly, this adds up to a desktop full of
paperwork. "I guess this is the natural progression of successful scientists,"
she said. "We direct and we teach." ![]()
| News | Contents | Wayne Medicine 1999 | Next Article | Previous Article |